Denver Summit's Top Goal Scorer Isn't a Forward. That's the Story of This Season.

A league-wide check found Janine Sonis is the only defender leading her own team in scoring anywhere in the NWSL. After Sunday's draw with Boston, that's not a quirky stat anymore — it's a diagnosis.

Denver, Colorado — Denver Summit had thirty-eight touches inside Boston Legacy's box on Sunday. Nine shots came out of it. One goal did too, and it came from the penalty spot, off the boot of a defender.

Boston's goal came first, in the 34th minute, and it came against the run of play. Keeper Casey Murphy launched a long ball that forward Sammy Smith ran onto and slotted past Abby Smith — Murphy's first career NWSL assist. Denver spent the rest of the match trying to answer it and didn't, not until the 72nd minute, when Janine Sonis buried a penalty won by Tash Flint to make it 1-1. That's how it stayed.

The final whistle read as a fair result if you only look at the scoreboard. It doesn't if you look at the box score. Thirty-eight touches in the box matched Denver's own season high, set three weeks earlier against Portland. Nine shots from inside the eighteen is a real number of looks. One goal is not.

The stat behind the stat

Sonis leads Denver Summit in scoring with seven goals this season, three of them from the penalty spot. On its own, that's a fun trivia answer — a defender leading a team in goals happens now and then, usually through set pieces. So the question worth asking is how unusual it actually is across the rest of the league.

A check of all sixteen NWSL clubs' leading scorers found twelve are led by a forward and three by a midfielder — including Wednesday's opponent, North Carolina Courage, where Ashley Sanchez sits second in the entire league with ten goals. Exactly one club in the league is led in scoring by a defender. That's Denver.

Sonis's seven goals put her sixth in the league's overall scoring race, tied with North Carolina's Evelyn Ijeh, ahead of players whose actual job is to find the net. It's a real credit to her — four straight converted penalties takes nerve, and she earned her Best XI honor back in May fair and square. But when your best goal-scoring threat plays center back, that's not a strength. It's an admission that the players whose job is to finish chances aren't finishing them.

Cushing's diagnosis, and his answer

Head coach Nick Cushing didn't dodge the problem in his postgame press conference. Describing a stoppage-time cross that went unclaimed in the 93rd minute, he said: "No number nine across the front, nobody trying to have the desire to get in and go win the game for Denver Summit. That is not the trait of a winning team."

He'd named Melissa Kössler and Olivia Thomas as the two players competing for that No. 9 role. Asked this week what either forward needs to show him in training to win the job outright, his answer suggested the competition isn't as open as it sounded three days earlier. "I don't think we've got any time to see anything in the sense of practice," he said. "I've been here before with number nine. I don't really need to see any more. I see a lot of hunger and a lot of ambition."

It's a coach betting on patience over a lineup change — that confidence, not a swap, solves this. It's defensible from a coach with his pedigree. It's also a harder case to make for a team that isn't creating marginally and coming up short, but overwhelmingly, and still walking away with one goal.

What Sonis is actually carrying

Sonis was candid in her own presser about what it means to be the one bailing the team out. "You don't get penalties when people aren't trying to create in the box," she said, crediting Flint and Lindsey Heaps for the run that won Sunday's spot kick. "Selfishly I would rather win than score a goal... I'd trade it all in to be up in the top four."

She also opened up about where her composure from twelve yards comes from. She missed a penalty at the 2019 World Cup — "the goalkeeper made a save, and ever since then I was like, I need to find redemption in some realm" — and rebuilt the habit into a daily routine, taking penalties after every training session since. Four for four this season says the rebuild worked. It's also a reminder that this entire storyline exists because Denver's forwards haven't built the same composure eighteen yards further out.

Reinforcements at the back

While the front line searches for answers, the back line got a real one. Denver signed Gemma Bonner on August 1 — Liverpool's all-time appearance leader, a two-time league-title captain there, and a four-year teammate of Cushing's at Manchester City. He wasn't shy about what she's for: "She's a winner... somebody that's gonna help our younger players, somebody that's gonna put demands and expectation on our senior players... push the character and personality of the team." Bonner joins a center-back group that already includes Kaleigh Kurtz, Eva Gaetino, and Meg Boade.

Natalie Means, subbed off with cramp in the 69th minute Sunday, got a shorter but pointed note from Cushing: real intensity, real versatility off the front or at outside back, but "probably needs to be a little bit more offensive in the way that she creates chances." At 22, she's one path to more end product that doesn't run through the No. 9 spot at all.

Where we go from here

This isn't one problem. It's at least two — a personnel question at forward that the coach has chosen to wait out rather than force, and a service question that patience alone won't fix, since thirty-eight touches in the box turning into nine shots means the ball isn't reliably finding people in dangerous spots even when Denver dominates the run of play.

A defender leading the team in scoring read as a quirky stat in June. In August, with the receipts showing it's the only case of it happening anywhere in the league, it reads as the whole season in one sentence. Denver hosts North Carolina Courage Wednesday at Centennial — first meeting ever between the clubs, and a real measuring stick against a team that's actually converting its chances.

Listen to the full episode breakdown at 5280pitch.com or wherever you get your podcasts.